About Us

Distinctive Diamonds is part of the DDM Arabov Group of companies. The entire Group is a certified member of the Responsible Jewellery Council (RJC). RJC certification confirms the Group’s commitment to responsible ethical, human rights, social and environmental practices in a transparent and accountable manner, from diamond sourcing through to retail. Only a limited number of prestigious retailers have achieved such standards.

The DDM Arabov Group is also a Diamond Trading Company (DTC, part of the De Beers Group) Sightholder. As a Sightholder, DDM Arabov Group is among a select number of diamantaires that receive direct supply from De Beers’ mines. All Sightholders undergo a rigorous selection process to ensure they are the world’s leading diamantaires. As a Sightholder, the entire Group adheres to De Beers Best Practice Principles. These principles are an independently monitored code/standard that gives consumers the confidence that international ethical, social and environmental standards have been met in the production of De Beers diamonds.

The DDM Arabov Group is proud to be both an RJC member and a DTC Sightholder. As part of DDM Arabov Group, Distinctive Diamonds benefits from industry-leading reputation and direct sourcing from De Beers’ mines.

About Jewelers in Indianapolis, IN

Distinctive Diamonds, a wholesale diamond company that has opened its doors to the public, offers you a different way to buy diamonds and jewelry from seasoned jewelers in Indianapolis. With diamond experts that use the Diamond Rapaport Report to reveal trade secrets of the industry and a certified diamond inventory larger than any other in the state, Distinctive Diamonds is revolutionizing the way diamonds are bought across the Midwest.

Our philosophy

Our philosophy is to sell diamonds to the consumer at the same prices that jewelers in Indianapolis IN pay. How do we do that? Distinctive Diamonds is the front office for a well-known diamond-cutting dynasty in Israel. Standing apart from the average jeweler Indianapolis has, our president, Eli Benisty, travels back home to Israel several times a year to buy diamonds from his family’s cutting company. For more than a decade, Eli sold his diamonds to local jewelers in Indianapolis and surrounding states. He now sells those diamonds directly to you for the same price that other jewelers in Indianapolis IN pay.

Distinctive Diamond’s Eli Benisty is the jeweler Indianapolis diamond enthusiasts and collectors have been waiting for.

When it comes to educating the customer Distinctive Diamonds does something very atypical. Our non-commissioned diamond experts reveal the Rapaport Diamond Report, the closely guarded wholesale pricing sheet of the diamond industry, and show you how diamonds are priced around the world. Much like the auto industry’s Blue Book, the Rapaport Diamond Report is a key to jewelers all over the world in pricing their diamonds. It is generally not a practice for the retailer to share it with customers. At Distinctive Diamonds we actually show you how the particular diamond you are shopping for is priced in other retail stores… then we show you OUR price and how much you are saving. We feel so confident in our ability to offer you so much quality without the markup; we are excited to share the Rapaport Diamond Report with you!!!

Distinctive Diamonds boasts one of the largest privately owned diamond inventories in the Midwest. And all of our diamonds are graded and certified by 3 independent gemological laboratories: The Gemological Institute of America (GIA), The European Gemological Laboratory (EGL), and the American Gem Society (AGS). Diamonds that are accompanied by these grading reports are the most highly valued in the industry, as their quality is considered guaranteed.

Since Distinctive Diamonds opened to the public, we have changed the way diamonds are sold in Indianapolis by setting the standard for quality, excellence, value and diamond education. Our success has brought media attention from the printed page to the spoken word. We are delighted to be participants in creating that “special diamond moment” for many happy couples in Indiana as well as surrounding states. We want to make acquiring the most beautiful diamond at the absolute best price a breeze.

 Free Lifetime Diamond Guarantee

At Distinctive Diamonds we will replace a diamond if lost out of your mounting. Please contact us for more details.

30 Day Money Back Guarantee

Our policy at Distinctive Diamonds is to give each customer a full 30 day money back guarantee (not a store credit) on the purchase of a diamond. This guarantee cannot be offered from a dealer who does not own the diamond he is selling. We want you to be thrilled with your diamond, not stuck with it.